Server you were banned on (SMP): SMP
Minecraft name: _JELLy__
Reason for your ban: Arguing with staff for disrespect
Who banned you: Vil
Why should you be unbanned: Here's the full story. I will put it in point form so every staff can see it clearly.
1. I built a gold farm in the gold farm world with 112 portals.
2. The tutorial say the limit for PUBLIC gold farms is 50 portals.
3. There is NO portal limit mentioned for private gold farm, in tutorial OR gold farm world thread.
4. Arrei in the Gold farm thread, upon me asking the limit, says 50 portal limit is for PUBLIC farms. I Quote in full text "Yeah, no, Frost has nothing to do with that rule. 50 is still the limit for public use. The issue there is simply that public use farms will see much more use and thus load entities more often."
5. I told Vil I was ready to have the warp removed to make it private and have no other player use it. I Quote from my own log "[17:56:26] [Client thread/INFO]: [CHAT] [Advanced] Jellie >> if you wanna take away from the public farm status remove the warp and i will have no other player
[17:56:28] [Client thread/INFO]: [CHAT] [Advanced] Jellie >> use the farm"
6. I did argue with Vil but with the points above I think my argument is justified. i made no disrespecting comments or any personal attacks.
7. Arrei just replied on the gold farm thread "There is no "half public, half private". Public farms may not have more than 50 portals loaded. Private farms do not have a specific limit, but all gold farms are limited by the fact that all pigmen must be within the 32 block activation radius." My farm, is within 32 block radius, in fact is is about 30 blocks from the center. And every pigmen will move with my minecart system.
8. I was given 2 choices by Vil who asserts that private farm has the same 50 portal limit (not by Arrei, creator of the gold world thread), cut it to 50 portals or continue arguing. I continued arguing for my right to keep my farm private and have more than 50 portals. Then I was banned, for disrespect...., for not arguing against any rule, nor disrespecting Vil.
Why do you want to come back: I love the community, and I am just trying to create another public resource farm with good efficiency. I know I do have a history of arguing with staff, but most of the time it is based on non-rules such as hopper changes. I do follow the rules, as what It is Written in tutorial or on threads. Upon seeing the 50 portal rule for public farms I asked arrei on the gold farm thread, and after that I was ready to have the farm revert to private. This Time I am arguing for a rule not written, only created by word of mouth. Furthermore I do not intend on disrespecting staff, I am simply arguing and made no attempts to disrespect Vil, if arguing is ever disrespect at all.
I have updated the appeal with quotes for more support and context.
Minecraft name: _JELLy__
Reason for your ban: Arguing with staff for disrespect
Who banned you: Vil
Why should you be unbanned: Here's the full story. I will put it in point form so every staff can see it clearly.
1. I built a gold farm in the gold farm world with 112 portals.
2. The tutorial say the limit for PUBLIC gold farms is 50 portals.
3. There is NO portal limit mentioned for private gold farm, in tutorial OR gold farm world thread.
4. Arrei in the Gold farm thread, upon me asking the limit, says 50 portal limit is for PUBLIC farms. I Quote in full text "Yeah, no, Frost has nothing to do with that rule. 50 is still the limit for public use. The issue there is simply that public use farms will see much more use and thus load entities more often."
5. I told Vil I was ready to have the warp removed to make it private and have no other player use it. I Quote from my own log "[17:56:26] [Client thread/INFO]: [CHAT] [Advanced] Jellie >> if you wanna take away from the public farm status remove the warp and i will have no other player
[17:56:28] [Client thread/INFO]: [CHAT] [Advanced] Jellie >> use the farm"
6. I did argue with Vil but with the points above I think my argument is justified. i made no disrespecting comments or any personal attacks.
7. Arrei just replied on the gold farm thread "There is no "half public, half private". Public farms may not have more than 50 portals loaded. Private farms do not have a specific limit, but all gold farms are limited by the fact that all pigmen must be within the 32 block activation radius." My farm, is within 32 block radius, in fact is is about 30 blocks from the center. And every pigmen will move with my minecart system.
8. I was given 2 choices by Vil who asserts that private farm has the same 50 portal limit (not by Arrei, creator of the gold world thread), cut it to 50 portals or continue arguing. I continued arguing for my right to keep my farm private and have more than 50 portals. Then I was banned, for disrespect...., for not arguing against any rule, nor disrespecting Vil.
Why do you want to come back: I love the community, and I am just trying to create another public resource farm with good efficiency. I know I do have a history of arguing with staff, but most of the time it is based on non-rules such as hopper changes. I do follow the rules, as what It is Written in tutorial or on threads. Upon seeing the 50 portal rule for public farms I asked arrei on the gold farm thread, and after that I was ready to have the farm revert to private. This Time I am arguing for a rule not written, only created by word of mouth. Furthermore I do not intend on disrespecting staff, I am simply arguing and made no attempts to disrespect Vil, if arguing is ever disrespect at all.
I have updated the appeal with quotes for more support and context.