• Welcome to the new forums! Server IP: smp.hometownmc.com
Hello There, Guest! Login Register


Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Ban Appeal / Minecraftmudere
#1
Sad 
Server you were banned on (SMP/Discord): SMP
Username : Minecraftmurdere
Reason for ban : Building a swastika and being generally offensive. 
Who banned you: Nether_Ruler

Why should you be unbanned: Greetings it has been a few months since playing on this server, I am a changed person and will adhere to the rules of this great server more vigilantly, I will not make the same mistakes I once did and strive to improve as a player! I am sorry to those whom I may have offended, and this is my first ban. I am to focus more on creation within this server and avoid public politics and builds that reference in real life politics, please allow me to show I am a changed player 


Why do you want to come back:
I enjoy this great server, the player base, the staff and the general atmosphere along with having been a donator of this server I wish to re-join this community as a newly improved person! Thank you for reading!  Cool
 
Reply
#2
I apologize for the delay in response. While I was the one that banned you, your behavior leading up to it involved repeated incidents observed by multiple staff members, so I felt it best to consult the rest of the team before responding.

After review, the staff consensus is that this appeal doesn't even remotely adequately address the severity (or pattern) of your actions. Prior to your ban, you were frequently argumentative in chat, often engaging in discussions that became inflammatory, politicized, and generally disruptive to other players' enjoyment of the server.

You've made repeated comments regarding Jewish people that are disparaging in nature. Hate speech, extremist symbolism, or targeting of any group (religious, ethnic, or otherwise) is strictly prohibited and fundamentally incompatible with the environment we try to maintain here. 

Your donation status is completely irrelevant. VIPs are not exempt from the rules, nor are they afforded leniency for violating them. 

The staff team is also in agreement that this appeal reads less like genuine reflection and more like you telling us what you think we want to hear in hopes of being unbanned.

With all that in mind, I'm going to ask you a few questions. I expect honest, thoughtful, and complete responses. Anything less will result in this appeal being denied. I am happy to provide the chat logs documenting every insulting remark you've made, but it's probably better for us both if I don't. Hopefully you have a good memory.

1) What actions led to your ban, and why were they unacceptable under our rules?
2) Explain why building a swastika is not acceptable on this server.
3) How did your repeated argumentative and inflammatory behavior affect other players' experience?
4) As I mentioned, you've made many comments about Jewish people. Why are these sorts of comments inappropriate, and why do they not belong in this community?
5) What concrete steps will you take to ensure this behavior does not happen again if you are unbanned?
6) Why should we trust that you understand the seriousness of this ban?
 
Reply
#3
Hi thanks for your response,
Sorry if the appeal came of as non genuine, I simply am trying to improve, 


1) What actions led to your ban, and why were they unacceptable under our rules?

I created a devilish swastika in my devil island, which now I will no longer generate political buildings or references to this as it may be offensive to different cultures societies and individuals along with pulling the server in a political environment where this server is meant for fun peace and friendship, politics and intense symbolism can create issues and barriers and conflict

2) Explain why building a swastika is not acceptable on this server.

This server wants to avoid controversial and offensive symbols for some and I understand that, as it may exclude others or maybe them think we are doing wrong

3) How did your repeated argumentative and inflammatory behavior affect other players' experience?

Yes I remember maybe when there was not a lot of people from other countries chatting in the morning there was no english writing in the chat and I felt excluded and strange so I lashed out about saying they need to speak english but now I accept these people simply converse in other formats and there are no rules against it and so in this Kingdom of minecraft we must adhere to the rules of reality or we can leave, the player doesn't make the rules he must follow

4) As I mentioned, you've made many comments about Jewish people. Why are these sorts of comments inappropriate, and why do they not belong in this community?

Yes I made some political statements regarding israel and what not, this is minecraft where we come to relax and unplug from reality not to be entrenched in politics and reality, we make this world to have a break.

5) What concrete steps will you take to ensure this behavior does not happen again if you are unbanned?

I am not going to discuss any politics on this server or things that may lead to it as I want people to be relaxed and us to live inside minecraft peacefully, 

6) Why should we trust that you understand the seriousness of this ban?



Everyone in my opinion deserves a second chance and if we give grace to me I will learn from my errors and continue building my minecraft reality dimension and keytown for all players, I wish for peace not conflict now

Sorry if I hurt anyone
thank you for reading and I wish you all health and abundaance
 
Reply
#4
minecraftmurdere Wrote:Hi thanks for your response,
Sorry if the appeal came of as non genuine, I simply am trying to improve, 


1) What actions led to your ban, and why were they unacceptable under our rules?

I created a devilish swastika in my devil island, which now I will no longer generate political buildings or references to this as it may be offensive to different cultures societies and individuals along with pulling the server in a political environment where this server is meant for fun peace and friendship, politics and intense symbolism can create issues and barriers and conflict

2) Explain why building a swastika is not acceptable on this server.

This server wants to avoid controversial and offensive symbols for some and I understand that, as it may exclude others or maybe them think we are doing wrong

3) How did your repeated argumentative and inflammatory behavior affect other players' experience?

Yes I remember maybe when there was not a lot of people from other countries chatting in the morning there was no english writing in the chat and I felt excluded and strange so I lashed out about saying they need to speak english but now I accept these people simply converse in other formats and there are no rules against it and so in this Kingdom of minecraft we must adhere to the rules of reality or we can leave, the player doesn't make the rules he must follow

4) As I mentioned, you've made many comments about Jewish people. Why are these sorts of comments inappropriate, and why do they not belong in this community?

Yes I made some political statements regarding israel and what not, this is minecraft where we come to relax and unplug from reality not to be entrenched in politics and reality, we make this world to have a break.

5) What concrete steps will you take to ensure this behavior does not happen again if you are unbanned?

I am not going to discuss any politics on this server or things that may lead to it as I want people to be relaxed and us to live inside minecraft peacefully, 

6) Why should we trust that you understand the seriousness of this ban?



Everyone in my opinion deserves a second chance and if we give grace to me I will learn from my errors and continue building my minecraft reality dimension and keytown for all players, I wish for peace not conflict now

Sorry if I hurt anyone
thank you for reading and I wish you all health and abundaance

Overall, this was the staff's opinions on your appeal:

[Image: 4Gkmbl8.png]

I have to agree with what the other staff members have to say regarding your response. It sounds a lot less like "I feel bad for what I did" and more "here is what you want to hear."
Things like this make me feel like you're being insincere:
minecraftmurdere Wrote:in this Kingdom of minecraft we must adhere to the rules
minecraftmurdere Wrote:I created a devilish swastika in my devil island

Also, just a note regarding this,
minecraftmurdere Wrote:This server wants to avoid controversial and offensive symbols for some and I understand that, as it may exclude others or maybe them think we are doing wrong

That's the issue: you ARE doing something wrong. This isn't a matter of difference of opinion. The things you would say to people (both in global and in DM) are downright heinous.

If your memory is failing you, here are some examples. The reason most of these didn't get you banned in the first place is because we don't police DMs, though I'd be lying if it didn't come up multiple times amongst the staff team. Players who are problematic in DMs are very typically also problematic in general. Case in point being the fact we're having this conversation in the first place.

2025-05-29-1.log:[15:44:14] [Async Chat Thread - #336/INFO]: [Member] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> speak english!
2025-05-29-1.log:[15:44:17] [Async Chat Thread - #336/INFO]: [Member] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> you are not in india
2025-05-29-1.log:[15:45:53] [Async Chat Thread - #336/INFO]: [Member] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> indians leave now
2025-05-29-1.log:[15:46:21] [Async Chat Thread - #336/INFO]: [Member] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> INDIAN LEAVE!
After which you were warned:
2025-05-29-1.log:[15:46:54] [Server thread/INFO]: Steasaur issued server command: /warn minecraftmurdere We do not speak to people and tell them to leave because of the language they speak.

And then again, a few weeks later. 

2025-06-13-1.log:[10:57:22] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> speak english!
2025-06-13-1.log: [10:57:22] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Member] .The1stNoobie » why
2025-06-13-1.log:[10:57:33] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> because this is an english reality
2025-06-13-1.log: [10:58:01] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> this server will become indian
2025-06-13-1.log:[10:58:56] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> yes and only 50% of india has internet imagine what will happen when you all get access
2025-06-13-1.log:[11:00:04] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> language is how humans communicate and socialise if there is now a divide on the server the social fabric of this server will begin to crumble
2025-06-13-1.log:[11:01:28] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Experienced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> Yes but you think frostvincent when he made the server he wanted all of us talking indian
2025-06-13-1.log:[11:01:56] [Async Chat Thread - #281/INFO]: [Admin] melaniebeedot❆ >> minecraftmurdere, vincent says everyone is welcome here no matter the language you speak

Some other highlights:

2025-07-11-1.log:[11:01:42] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /msg [REDACTED] indians love white people but migration policies are not good for us they will breed too much
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:06:52] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r vicious will and preserved blood, desire to be tribal to their own with the sustained intellect, imagine what will happen when these people unify
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:07:27] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r “My spirit will rise from the grave and the world will see i was right.”― Adolf Hitler
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:08:09] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r yes but in these last 2 years more minds have been freed than the last decade
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:09:26] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r it's all true
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:09:48] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r stupid leaders
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:11:24] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r But do they think they can actually erase us? Because they do not understand our will
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:12:06] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Our will cannot be conquerered, we rule fate, we are the people that reach to the stars
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:12:36] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Because of weak men
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:12:40] [Server thread/INFO]: UltimateEmil issued server command: /msg minecraftmurdere true
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:12:52] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r I never blame women ever, their actions are a byproduct of weak men
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:13:07] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Women are simply attracted to masculinity and will
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:13:27] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r if the white will is submissive of course she will be more inclined to go towards the active
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:14:12] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Because white people have forgotten their righteous archetype and try play a archetype of a comedian or homer simpson or some foolery
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:15:15] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r When white people follow their nature white woman fall in love with white men
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:16:23] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Whites will have enough soon
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:17:33] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r your people are too civilised that's why
2025-07-22-1.log:[12:17:44] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r they hacked you
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-05-16-1.log:[13:04:50] [Async Chat Thread - #460/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁎ >> i need slave labour in the hell dimension
2025-05-16-1.log:[13:05:02] [Async Chat Thread - #460/INFO]: [Admin] melaniebeedot❆ » lets not call it that
2025-05-16-1.log:[13:05:09] [Async Chat Thread - #460/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁎ >> ok forgive me
Then, 2 hours later:
2025-05-16-2.log:[15:59:53] [Async Chat Thread - #28/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁎ >> thanks for your work you can go home now
2025-05-16-2.log:[16:01:40] [Member] LailyDreamer ⁂ » ash when did you bought vip
2025-05-16-2.log:[16:01:57] [Async Chat Thread - #28/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁎ >> she did slave labour for me .LailyDreamer
[Image: ZDID0J1.png]
2025-05-16-2.log:[16:02:55] [Async Chat Thread - #29/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁎ >> because she did slave labour for me
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-05-20-3.log:[20:43:15] [Async Chat Thread - #57/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> There was a strange people that infilitrated Germany and bankrupt the economy, ended up owning all the media and banks
2025-05-20-3.log:[20:44:11] [Async Chat Thread - #57/INFO]: [Regular] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> history is a lie
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-07-17-2.log:[19:28:37] [Async Chat Thread - #5/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> yeah and you don't let strange people infest your country
("Strange people" referring to migrants, btw)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-06-30-2.log:[20:47:06] [parties-pool-69/INFO]: [Parties] minecraftmurdere sent a party message to Devilry: you see the jews have designed this reality where we are made to hate one another, if everyone was in their rightful place there would be less hate
I hope the irony of you perpetuating hate while talking about less hate isn't lost on you.
2025-06-30-2.log:[20:47:48] [parties-pool-69/INFO]: [Parties] minecraftmurdere sent a party message to Devilry: if they become the majority and implement their laws it will not be good
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-07-10-2.log:[23:25:27] [Async Chat Thread - #34/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> gay nazi is scary
2025-07-10-2.log:[23:25:40] [Async Chat Thread - #34/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> doesn't make sense
2025-07-10-2.log:[23:26:40] [Async Chat Thread - #34/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> don't hate the nazis if you know history
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-07-08-1.log:[14:48:23] [Async Chat Thread - #395/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> white
2025-07-08-1.log:[14:48:27] [Async Chat Thread - #395/INFO]: [Advanced] minecraftmurdere ⁂ >> white is right
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:58:02] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r mass programming
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:58:24] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r But the enemies do not know they are playing with fire
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:58:44] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r Truly they cannot fathom what happens when you push the white spirit to its limit
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:58:58] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r even though one man almost conquered the whole globe with his will
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:59:04] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r austrian painter
2025-07-21-1.log:[11:59:28] [Server thread/INFO]: [REDACTED] issued server command: /msg minecraftmurdere europeans are very powerful. thats why they want us gone. erased from this earth
2025-07-21-1.log:[12:00:20] [Server thread/INFO]: minecraftmurdere issued server command: /r yes, we are each a one man army of philosophy, battle and spirit, a polymath of reality


And of course, to top it all off, the reason(s) you were directly banned in the first place:
[Image: BCnmk5a.png]

[Image: GSYKFnB.png]
[Image: jDoWhP5.png]



And then, as if ALL of that wasn't yet enough, you evaded your ban and came online on another account to leave a message for another player. The only reason ban evasion wasn't added to your ban was because you left immediately.

[Image: na9Wtga.png]
[Image: D6Yarbe.png]
[Image: EBiFvAG.png]
[Image: IB47LAv.png]

With all this considered, I hope you see why myself, along with the rest of the team, think your response is a bit lackluster.
 
Reply
#5
Hi thank you for your response, yes I was disrespectful to the indian players and I place full responsibility on that! Sorry to my indian friends. that was a wrong thing to say and I take full accountability. That is karma as the indians say.

Regarding my personal messages yes, I think these should of been kept to themselves as this is a conversation between me and my great friend, what I say in my personal messages is mostly true, white genocide is happening but I don't want to get political as history is written by the winners, havara agreement). And it would enter the realm of politics which I don't want to go into

Steasaur is homosexual and he is a great person
I said to never hate women in my messages
I apologised for my political displays

I simply wish for another chance to reveal my changed behaviour, I think it is true my belief systems are different to perhaps many of the staff but I simply do believe in common ground and respecting people in the game, Also regarding theslave labour joke it was dark humor yes and I will be more vigiliant next time

Ultimately, I thank you for responding and you have gone into depth to your perspective and I respect it as if I was in your shoes Iwould understand, but what I can say is, is that I will not reference politics on the server again and simply want to build in peace on keytown and finish my giant tree.

What I will improve
> No politics!
> No drama!
> No hatred!

What I apologise for
> Disrespecting a group of people on the server
> Creating political and offensive buildings
> My skin was also seen as offensive
> Dark humor that can be considered offensive
-----------------------------------
What I request consideration
> These personal messages are my individual politics discussing with my friend
> I love gay people
> I care for the world
> I want to improve as a player

Thank you for reading again

bless you all. !
 
Reply
  


Forum Jump:


Browsing: 2 Guest(s)